IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

..et d'autres discussions ennuyeuses
User avatar
The Bytown Boozer
Registered Broad
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:29 am
Has given rep: 241 times
Received rep: 160 times
Contact:

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1601 by The Bytown Boozer » Fri Mar 17, 2017 7:27 pm

Dog wrote:... the intolerant, exclusionary extremes.


What you're describing here is mainstream, organized religion.

The kind where we should distrust "infidels". The kind where we try to tell people what bathrooms they should use. The kind that believes that God promised only us, and our like-minded brethren, a certain batch of land. It's all very much exclusionary, Dog.
User avatar
The Bytown Boozer
Registered Broad
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:29 am
Has given rep: 241 times
Received rep: 160 times
Contact:

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1602 by The Bytown Boozer » Fri Mar 17, 2017 7:37 pm

Dog wrote:
The Bytown Boozer wrote:
Dog wrote:... the intolerant, exclusionary extremes.


What you're describing here is mainstream, organized religion.

The kind where we should distrust "infidels". The kind where we try to tell people what bathrooms they should use. The kind that believes that God promised only us, and our like-minded brethren, a certain batch of land. It's all very much exclusionary, Dog.


Nah, mainstream is wishy washy.

Then where the fuck are these people? They certainly seem to be absent whenever the church trots out its dogmatic discourse.
User avatar
The Bytown Boozer
Registered Broad
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:29 am
Has given rep: 241 times
Received rep: 160 times
Contact:

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1603 by The Bytown Boozer » Fri Mar 17, 2017 7:48 pm

Dog wrote:
The Bytown Boozer wrote:
Dog wrote:
Nah, mainstream is wishy washy.

Then where the fuck are these people? They certainly seem to be absent whenever the church trots out its dogmatic discourse.


They are the ones not in the news?

:dunno:

I agree that the news would probably not receive an immense boost in ratings by airing the grievances of moderate Lutherans, but you'd think that if these views really did represent the mainstream of religion there would at least be some visible pushback against the ultra-Conservative factions of the modern church.
User avatar
The Bytown Boozer
Registered Broad
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:29 am
Has given rep: 241 times
Received rep: 160 times
Contact:

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1604 by The Bytown Boozer » Fri Mar 17, 2017 7:49 pm

Ugh... and don't even get me started on sports fans...... :paulrus:
User avatar
The Bytown Boozer
Registered Broad
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:29 am
Has given rep: 241 times
Received rep: 160 times
Contact:

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1605 by The Bytown Boozer » Fri Mar 17, 2017 8:06 pm

The reality is that most religious people are simply not interested in hearing what a secular heathen such as you or I have to say on this matter. We are excluded from any discourse on religious tolerance because we are from the dreaded "outgroup".
User avatar
The Bytown Boozer
Registered Broad
Posts: 1873
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 4:29 am
Has given rep: 241 times
Received rep: 160 times
Contact:

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1606 by The Bytown Boozer » Fri Mar 17, 2017 8:08 pm

I've tried to have this conversation with religious people and at a certain point you either need to change the topic of the conversation or you'll have to get ready for what will no doubt end in a shouting match where no one is listening to one another.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1607 by AD » Fri Mar 17, 2017 9:39 pm

But religion is just a reflection of us.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1608 by AD » Fri Mar 17, 2017 9:41 pm

Wait
.. my last comment was directed at something Boozy said last page. Didn't realise you gents are now on to sports fans.

Carry on.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1609 by AD » Sat Mar 18, 2017 8:57 am

It was!
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1610 by AD » Sat Mar 18, 2017 8:57 am

And they are!
User avatar
vf
Registered Broad
Posts: 11335
Joined: Fri Dec 11, 2009 11:31 pm
Has given rep: 560 times
Received rep: 308 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1611 by vf » Wed Apr 12, 2017 7:22 pm

So popular thoughts on the Haredi destroying Israel through religious stupidity?
User avatar
PredsFan77
Posts: 17027
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 12:53 am
Location: 7 TIME LOUNGE JEOPARDY CHAMP!!!
Has given rep: 150 times
Received rep: 485 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1612 by PredsFan77 » Mon May 08, 2017 5:55 pm

Image
CDX.NA.IG.9









[LEFT]Image[/LEFT]
User avatar
PredsFan77
Posts: 17027
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 12:53 am
Location: 7 TIME LOUNGE JEOPARDY CHAMP!!!
Has given rep: 150 times
Received rep: 485 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1613 by PredsFan77 » Mon May 08, 2017 5:56 pm

CDX.NA.IG.9



















[LEFT]Image[/LEFT]
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1614 by Whit Dickman » Mon Mar 18, 2019 2:56 pm

So it's been a couple of years and I have some things to say.

I probably oversold the influence of Islamic doctrine, but continue to hold basically the same position regarding the ills of religious dogmatism. Of course, religious dogmatism is much further down the list of important problems that we are facing than it was even 2 years ago. [I'll add that those who might have disagreed with my argument about the Islamic religion holding some blame for the behaviour of the minority of bad Muslims are likely to make the exact same argument now when it comes to white nationalism. I.e., the vast majority of white nationalists don't murder anyone, but the ideology is still relevant to the outliers and therefore requires sustained criticism.]

At any rate, legitimate Islamophobia is now certainly a more significant problem than Islamic religious dogmatism. I did not anticipate this and I feel bad about it. I don't know what role the "criticism" of Islam (from people like Sam Harris, etc.) played in all this - certainly less than Trump and the rise of nationalism - but I am not happy about my association with this sort of thing. (I was always pro-immigration... it helps people escape theocracies and benefit from secularism)

In short, we are at a point where criticizing Islam (reminder: not Muslims, but Islam) probably does more damage than good. It emboldens racists and, anyway, probably cannot be done in such a way that it would be easily separable from racism for the target audience of the criticism. I freely admit that this might have been the case 2-3 years ago as well, but I just didn't see it. So, mea culpa.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1615 by AD » Mon Mar 18, 2019 3:07 pm

If you go back to the thread, you'll see that most here (probably not on Twitter and Reddit, but here) equated all dogmatism and blamed all narrow views (whether political, social, religious, etc.) for certain behaviours... and were generally simply pointing out that blaming/singling out Islam was the problematic part of your argument.

But good job on that post.
User avatar
PredsFan77
Posts: 17027
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 12:53 am
Location: 7 TIME LOUNGE JEOPARDY CHAMP!!!
Has given rep: 150 times
Received rep: 485 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1616 by PredsFan77 » Mon Mar 18, 2019 6:57 pm

we'll all look back at the events of this year when world war 3 is discussed
CDX.NA.IG.9



















[LEFT]Image[/LEFT]
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1617 by Whit Dickman » Tue Mar 19, 2019 6:15 pm

AD wrote:If you go back to the thread, you'll see that most here (probably not on Twitter and Reddit, but here) equated all dogmatism and blamed all narrow views (whether political, social, religious, etc.) for certain behaviours... and were generally simply pointing out that blaming/singling out Islam was the problematic part of your argument.

But good job on that post.


Okay, so I guess another analogy would be: Are we justified in now singling out nationalism given recent events?

I would say yes. Just as it was justified to be singling out Islam when ISIS was throwing gay people from the tops of buildings. Naturally, as I've intimated, the complication here is that the "singling out" of Islam is related to the rise of actual Islamophobia.

So, it's not that things can't be singled out. But that it was (in this narrow case) predictable that singling out Islam would embolden racists.


Perhaps that's what you're saying.

Okay, fair enough.
User avatar
Dr_Chimera
Registered Broad
Posts: 9381
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 12:50 pm
Has given rep: 163 times
Received rep: 499 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1618 by Dr_Chimera » Tue Mar 19, 2019 7:22 pm

I don't get the analogy between Islam and white nationalism at all. Is this what they're teaching over at Yale these days? That Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Ben Shapiro are both equally bad?
User avatar
mayoradamwest
Registered Broad
Posts: 10472
Joined: Mon Nov 17, 2008 8:38 pm
Has given rep: 379 times
Received rep: 209 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1619 by mayoradamwest » Tue Mar 19, 2019 9:00 pm

Extremists from both groups is the comparison I usually see :dunno:
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1620 by AD » Wed Mar 20, 2019 9:57 am

Whit Dickman wrote:
AD wrote:If you go back to the thread, you'll see that most here (probably not on Twitter and Reddit, but here) equated all dogmatism and blamed all narrow views (whether political, social, religious, etc.) for certain behaviours... and were generally simply pointing out that blaming/singling out Islam was the problematic part of your argument.

But good job on that post.


Okay, so I guess another analogy would be: Are we justified in now singling out nationalism given recent events?

I would say yes. Just as it was justified to be singling out Islam when ISIS was throwing gay people from the tops of buildings. Naturally, as I've intimated, the complication here is that the "singling out" of Islam is related to the rise of actual Islamophobia.

So, it's not that things can't be singled out. But that it was (in this narrow case) predictable that singling out Islam would embolden racists.


Perhaps that's what you're saying.

Okay, fair enough.


I mean, I don't think its fair to say that white nationalism is somehow the worst thing ever or singling it out as unique.

The general assumption is that people suck, are stupid, and fucked up and some will get drawn into whatever extremism gives them purpose at whatever time or whatever extremism is accepted within a community, whatever gets them validation as humans, yadda yadda.

And that the tenets of the -ism in question are pretty secondary.

Hence, going from one current problematic -ism to another to another misses the actual issue, usually a human feeling of disenfranchisement and injustice coupled with some internal struggle sprinkled with assholishness and criminality.

And that is especially problematic if the -ism you're pointing to as problematic is generally and historically identical to other -isms that don't produce the violent outcomes. Example, Islam vs Christianity vs Judaism are so identical and similar, singling one of them as producing violent and extremist behaviour is the wrongness we argued.

Nationalism, like religious thought, has its issues, but when its basically be proud of your territory, language and sing songs a few times a year, its fine.
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1621 by Whit Dickman » Wed Mar 20, 2019 5:59 pm

Dr_Chimera wrote:I don't get the analogy between Islam and white nationalism at all. Is this what they're teaching over at Yale these days? That Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Ben Shapiro are both equally bad?


The analogy isn't between the ideologies. The idea is that people are happy to "blame" white nationalism as an ideology (that is, the connection between their ideology and various bad behaviors is readily apparent), but when it comes to religions (and Islam in particular) the ideology (ideologies) gets a pass.

But that's not how human behavior works. People pick up beliefs throughout their lives, and these beliefs have impacts on what they do in the world. Particularly those beliefs that they internalize in the key formative years of their lives.

AD wrote:I mean, I don't think its fair to say that white nationalism is somehow the worst thing ever or singling it out as unique.

The general assumption is that people suck, are stupid, and fucked up and some will get drawn into whatever extremism gives them purpose at whatever time or whatever extremism is accepted within a community, whatever gets them validation as humans, yadda yadda.

And that the tenets of the -ism in question are pretty secondary.

Hence, going from one current problematic -ism to another to another misses the actual issue, usually a human feeling of disenfranchisement and injustice coupled with some internal struggle sprinkled with assholishness and criminality.

And that is especially problematic if the -ism you're pointing to as problematic is generally and historically identical to other -isms that don't produce the violent outcomes. Example, Islam vs Christianity vs Judaism are so identical and similar, singling one of them as producing violent and extremist behaviour is the wrongness we argued.

Nationalism, like religious thought, has its issues, but when its basically be proud of your territory, language and sing songs a few times a year, its fine.


I'm sorry AD, but you're just wrong.

People do not just choose among beliefs in the way that you imply. The things we are taught (and believe) have impacts on what we do. Even the most rational and fully developed adult cannot really interpret novel claims ("-isms") outside the lens of the things they already believe (the "-isms" that have been handed to them, in whole or in part).

Let's consider a more straightforward context. Have you noticed how everyone always likes (primarily) music from their era? This is a context where absolutely nothing is at stake. People's preferences about what sounds good is, in relative terms, almost entirely arbitrary. People could, in theory, listen to music from any time or any culture. There is no stigma attached to doing so (unlike for religion), and they have easy access to a great wealth of music. But the vast majority nonetheless retain their preferences for music that they listened to during their formative years.

If the formation of musical preferences over time is so easily influenced by what was learned at a given point in time, imagine the influence of being exposed to an entire belief system? And I'm not talking about the exceptions - white nationalism and all that - I'm talking about how my brain works and your brain works and how Chim's brain works and how Jester's brain... well, nevermind Jester.

And, not just that, but you're suggesting that people's disenfranchisement has nothing to do with their having adopted disenfranchised belief systems. By my reading, the primary reason behind the new rise in white nationalism is that whites feel like they are becoming more disenfranchised ("not allowed to make racist jokes anymore... and, look, black kids are getting into college now"). The disenfranchisement isn't coherent unless the beliefs are already in place (in this context, that "whites" are "us" and "everyone else" is "them" - simplifying things of course).

Mental health is a relevant factor, but one cannot talk about these things without considering the things that people actually believe. The brain just doesn't work that way, AD.
User avatar
Dr_Chimera
Registered Broad
Posts: 9381
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 12:50 pm
Has given rep: 163 times
Received rep: 499 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1622 by Dr_Chimera » Wed Mar 20, 2019 8:13 pm

mayoradamwest wrote:Extremists from both groups is the comparison I usually see :dunno:


White nationalists are already extremists.
User avatar
Dr_Chimera
Registered Broad
Posts: 9381
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 12:50 pm
Has given rep: 163 times
Received rep: 499 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1623 by Dr_Chimera » Wed Mar 20, 2019 8:14 pm

Whit Dickman wrote:The analogy isn't between the ideologies. The idea is that people are happy to "blame" white nationalism as an ideology (that is, the connection between their ideology and various bad behaviors is readily apparent), but when it comes to religions (and Islam in particular) the ideology (ideologies) gets a pass.


That's because white nationalism is bad and Islam isn't.

Imagine Dickman in another couple of years: "So it's been a couple of years and I have some things to say."
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1624 by AD » Wed Mar 20, 2019 8:49 pm

Whit Dickman wrote:
Dr_Chimera wrote:I don't get the analogy between Islam and white nationalism at all. Is this what they're teaching over at Yale these days? That Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Ben Shapiro are both equally bad?


The analogy isn't between the ideologies. The idea is that people are happy to "blame" white nationalism as an ideology (that is, the connection between their ideology and various bad behaviors is readily apparent), but when it comes to religions (and Islam in particular) the ideology (ideologies) gets a pass.

But that's not how human behavior works. People pick up beliefs throughout their lives, and these beliefs have impacts on what they do in the world. Particularly those beliefs that they internalize in the key formative years of their lives.

AD wrote:I mean, I don't think its fair to say that white nationalism is somehow the worst thing ever or singling it out as unique.

The general assumption is that people suck, are stupid, and fucked up and some will get drawn into whatever extremism gives them purpose at whatever time or whatever extremism is accepted within a community, whatever gets them validation as humans, yadda yadda.

And that the tenets of the -ism in question are pretty secondary.

Hence, going from one current problematic -ism to another to another misses the actual issue, usually a human feeling of disenfranchisement and injustice coupled with some internal struggle sprinkled with assholishness and criminality.

And that is especially problematic if the -ism you're pointing to as problematic is generally and historically identical to other -isms that don't produce the violent outcomes. Example, Islam vs Christianity vs Judaism are so identical and similar, singling one of them as producing violent and extremist behaviour is the wrongness we argued.

Nationalism, like religious thought, has its issues, but when its basically be proud of your territory, language and sing songs a few times a year, its fine.


I'm sorry AD, but you're just wrong.

People do not just choose among beliefs in the way that you imply. The things we are taught (and believe) have impacts on what we do. Even the most rational and fully developed adult cannot really interpret novel claims ("-isms") outside the lens of the things they already believe (the "-isms" that have been handed to them, in whole or in part).

Let's consider a more straightforward context. Have you noticed how everyone always likes (primarily) music from their era? This is a context where absolutely nothing is at stake. People's preferences about what sounds good is, in relative terms, almost entirely arbitrary. People could, in theory, listen to music from any time or any culture. There is no stigma attached to doing so (unlike for religion), and they have easy access to a great wealth of music. But the vast majority nonetheless retain their preferences for music that they listened to during their formative years.

If the formation of musical preferences over time is so easily influenced by what was learned at a given point in time, imagine the influence of being exposed to an entire belief system? And I'm not talking about the exceptions - white nationalism and all that - I'm talking about how my brain works and your brain works and how Chim's brain works and how Jester's brain... well, nevermind Jester.

And, not just that, but you're suggesting that people's disenfranchisement has nothing to do with their having adopted disenfranchised belief systems. By my reading, the primary reason behind the new rise in white nationalism is that whites feel like they are becoming more disenfranchised ("not allowed to make racist jokes anymore... and, look, black kids are getting into college now"). The disenfranchisement isn't coherent unless the beliefs are already in place (in this context, that "whites" are "us" and "everyone else" is "them" - simplifying things of course).

Mental health is a relevant factor, but one cannot talk about these things without considering the things that people actually believe. The brain just doesn't work that way, AD.


I didn't say any if what you say I'm wrong about!

What is the difference between the monotheistic Abrahamic religions, in their tenets, that make one worst than the others?
User avatar
clawfirst
Registered Broad
Posts: 23847
Joined: Sat May 10, 2008 1:45 pm
Has given rep: 295 times
Received rep: 497 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1625 by clawfirst » Wed Mar 20, 2019 9:05 pm

Adhering to said tenants...
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1626 by AD » Wed Mar 20, 2019 9:31 pm

clawfirst wrote:Adhering to said tenants...


Exactly.
User avatar
jester
Registered Broad
Posts: 7108
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 2:38 pm
Has given rep: 10 times
Received rep: 134 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1627 by jester » Thu Mar 21, 2019 12:03 am

I appreciate the shot at me. I mean, who would have thought nationalism might be mobilized malevolently? Shocking (and entirely predictable) development, that one.

Going back two years, when your rhetoric and Trump's rhetoric were aligned, that probably should have given some pause.
User avatar
jester
Registered Broad
Posts: 7108
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 2:38 pm
Has given rep: 10 times
Received rep: 134 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1628 by jester » Thu Mar 21, 2019 12:14 am

AD wrote:What is the difference between the monotheistic Abrahamic religions, in their tenets, that make one worst than the others?


What's always been dumb about this is that in some future scenario it's possible to imagine militarized veganism. Humans have been slaughtering each other long enough that we should have some humility in prescribing the ills of man as somehow unique to anything. The more important question is what tempers those impulses, and the secularism argument has always had numerous flaws. One of the most obvious? Nationalism, of which race/ethnicity-based nationalism has been the most dangerous.

Hopefully Europe doesn't implode before we get the current iteration reined in.
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1629 by Whit Dickman » Thu Mar 21, 2019 12:40 am

Haha there is no way that I'm getting sucked back into this conversation. I said my bit. Peace out mofos
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1630 by Whit Dickman » Thu Mar 21, 2019 12:46 am

Dr_Chimera wrote:
Whit Dickman wrote:The analogy isn't between the ideologies. The idea is that people are happy to "blame" white nationalism as an ideology (that is, the connection between their ideology and various bad behaviors is readily apparent), but when it comes to religions (and Islam in particular) the ideology (ideologies) gets a pass.


That's because white nationalism is bad and Islam isn't.

Imagine Dickman in another couple of years: "So it's been a couple of years and I have some things to say."


Okay one more thing and then I'm out:



K now I'm out
User avatar
Dr_Chimera
Registered Broad
Posts: 9381
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 12:50 pm
Has given rep: 163 times
Received rep: 499 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1631 by Dr_Chimera » Thu Mar 21, 2019 1:05 am

Whit is going to be shocked when he learns about the shit Christians did.
User avatar
Dr_Chimera
Registered Broad
Posts: 9381
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 12:50 pm
Has given rep: 163 times
Received rep: 499 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1632 by Dr_Chimera » Thu Mar 21, 2019 1:24 am

Yale University George W. Bush school of Islamophobia Studies presents Whit Dickman's paper "Why the people we're bombing are to blame for terrorism."
User avatar
Craig
Registered Broad
Posts: 18377
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 4:33 pm
Location: Toronto
Has given rep: 32 times
Received rep: 428 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1633 by Craig » Thu Mar 21, 2019 4:04 am

Dr_Chimera wrote:Whit is going to be shocked when he learns about the shit Christians did.


He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.
User avatar
jester
Registered Broad
Posts: 7108
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 2:38 pm
Has given rep: 10 times
Received rep: 134 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1634 by jester » Thu Mar 21, 2019 7:47 am

Craig wrote:
Dr_Chimera wrote:Whit is going to be shocked when he learns about the shit Christians did.


He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.


Meh, he's repeatedly displayed his animus largely derives from contemporary news reports (which have been repeatedly shown to have an anti-Muslim bias) and not much else. He isn't alone, of course, lots of people don't really take stock of WWI and WWII, and what would likely have happened if not for nukes. Western exceptionalism, of which this is very much a part, is excellent at ignoring its warts.

But, hey, at least he recognizes Nazis are a problem now! (Note: this required contemporary news coverage/events.)
User avatar
Dr_Chimera
Registered Broad
Posts: 9381
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 12:50 pm
Has given rep: 163 times
Received rep: 499 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1635 by Dr_Chimera » Thu Mar 21, 2019 11:26 pm

Clearly I've not read enough of this thread.

(good)
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1636 by Whit Dickman » Sat Mar 30, 2019 1:03 pm

User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1637 by Whit Dickman » Sat Mar 30, 2019 1:03 pm

Craig wrote:
Dr_Chimera wrote:Whit is going to be shocked when he learns about the shit Christians did.


He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.


Correct Craig. Thank you craig
User avatar
Whit Dickman
Registered Broad
Posts: 3457
Joined: Mon Jun 08, 2015 10:56 pm
Has given rep: 77 times
Received rep: 194 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1638 by Whit Dickman » Sat Mar 30, 2019 1:05 pm

jester wrote:
Craig wrote:
Dr_Chimera wrote:Whit is going to be shocked when he learns about the shit Christians did.


He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.


Meh, he's repeatedly displayed his animus largely derives from contemporary news reports (which have been repeatedly shown to have an anti-Muslim bias) and not much else. He isn't alone, of course, lots of people don't really take stock of WWI and WWII, and what would likely have happened if not for nukes. Western exceptionalism, of which this is very much a part, is excellent at ignoring its warts.

But, hey, at least he recognizes Nazis are a problem now! (Note: this required contemporary news coverage/events.)


If something deserves special attention, what else would it be based on (but media reports)?

We're talking about white nationalism more now because of media reports. That is, because of what is happening in the world.
User avatar
jester
Registered Broad
Posts: 7108
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 2:38 pm
Has given rep: 10 times
Received rep: 134 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1639 by jester » Sat Mar 30, 2019 3:17 pm

Whit Dickman wrote:
jester wrote:
Craig wrote:
He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.


Meh, he's repeatedly displayed his animus largely derives from contemporary news reports (which have been repeatedly shown to have an anti-Muslim bias) and not much else. He isn't alone, of course, lots of people don't really take stock of WWI and WWII, and what would likely have happened if not for nukes. Western exceptionalism, of which this is very much a part, is excellent at ignoring its warts.

But, hey, at least he recognizes Nazis are a problem now! (Note: this required contemporary news coverage/events.)


If something deserves special attention, what else would it be based on (but media reports)?

We're talking about white nationalism more now because of see Zfmedia reports. That is, because of what is happening in the world.


You think white nationalism is a new and sudden development? Or are you suddenly aware of it? I (and many, many others) didn't find Trump so alarming because white nationalist thought was a novel and unknown entity.

FFS, it's one of the most salient and insidious features of North American history.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1640 by AD » Sun Mar 31, 2019 10:36 pm

Whit Dickman wrote:
Craig wrote:
Dr_Chimera wrote:Whit is going to be shocked when he learns about the shit Christians did.


He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.


Correct Craig. Thank you craig


Christianity hasn't outgrown Christianity.

A lot of historically Christian political entities have moved away from Christianity momentarily. That doesn't change what Christianity is. Especially since these movements are themselves different year to year. You can't define Christianity by what you, in Canada, in a secular generally atheistic view, believe Christianity to be. All the while defining Islam by its most extreme views as shown to you through secular and Christian Canadian media.

These religions that you are comparing and contrasting have been on earth for Millenia. Defining them by a snapshot taken at any one time is dumb. Defining them by a skewed snapshot is even worse.

But even if you want to play this game.. You need to tell me how Judaism is less of a problem than Islam right now.
User avatar
Craig
Registered Broad
Posts: 18377
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 4:33 pm
Location: Toronto
Has given rep: 32 times
Received rep: 428 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1641 by Craig » Sun Mar 31, 2019 10:43 pm

What I don't get is how you think religions can outgrow their badness, then turn around and criticise the religion for the acts of its adherents instead of the socio-economic and geopolitical conditions that surround it. I don't think religions outgrow their nasties on their own, external things change their constituents who in turn moderate their religion.
User avatar
shredz
Registered Broad
Posts: 34073
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 3:31 pm
Location: Rock Bottom, NY
Has given rep: 2159 times
Received rep: 1048 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1642 by shredz » Sun Mar 31, 2019 10:54 pm

Sabbatai Zevi's cult movement lives on yet its story has been rubbed out of history books. The Rothschilds are the Sabbateans of today. Half of the Jews of the world followed this man as the Messiah plunging Judaism into darkness in 1666. If Sabbateans are so willing to sacrifice millions of their own people in the name of Eretz Israel, what will they not be prepared to do to the rest of the 'Goyim' world?
User avatar
shredz
Registered Broad
Posts: 34073
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 3:31 pm
Location: Rock Bottom, NY
Has given rep: 2159 times
Received rep: 1048 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1643 by shredz » Sun Mar 31, 2019 11:01 pm

AD wrote:
Whit Dickman wrote:
Craig wrote:
He knows, he just thinks Christianity has outgrown it. Islam hasn't, so it deserves special attention.


Correct Craig. Thank you craig


Christianity hasn't outgrown Christianity.

A lot of historically Christian political entities have moved away from Christianity momentarily. That doesn't change what Christianity is. Especially since these movements are themselves different year to year. You can't define Christianity by what you, in Canada, in a secular generally atheistic view, believe Christianity to be. All the while defining Islam by its most extreme views as shown to you through secular and Christian Canadian media.

These religions that you are comparing and contrasting have been on earth for Millenia. Defining them by a snapshot taken at any one time is dumb. Defining them by a skewed snapshot is even worse.

But even if you want to play this game.. You need to tell me how Judaism is less of a problem than Islam right now.


The Left Hand of Judaism (not all Jews) does its work in cryptic fashion. Christian/Catholic in public, Jewish at home. Islam is thrown in our faces daily with mostly negative overtones. One works in the shadows. The other in broad daylight. Of course not many will have the knowledge, to truly know that opportunist 'Jews' are pulling more strings than Islam could ever dream of. The hand that moves the chess pieces. We only see the board.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1644 by AD » Mon Apr 01, 2019 7:45 am

Craig wrote:What I don't get is how you think religions can outgrow their badness, then turn around and criticise the religion for the acts of its adherents instead of the socio-economic and geopolitical conditions that surround it. I don't think religions outgrow their nasties on their own, external things change their constituents who in turn moderate their religion.


Stop saying things that I want to say in less words than me, Craig.



Also.. EB:

I'm still waiting on the current rankings of bad thoughts.

I guess in the last power rankings, because of Christchurch, White Nationalisn is back on top? First time since 1945? It had a short slump eh?

1. White Nationalisn
2. Islam
3. ???
4. ???
5.

Come on EB. Surely if there's a top 2, you can continue.
User avatar
Boring Choice #2
Posts: 6607
Joined: Fri Dec 28, 1979 6:06 am
Has given rep: 541 times
Received rep: 580 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1645 by Boring Choice #2 » Mon Apr 01, 2019 8:44 am

If you change, white nationalism to right-wing fundamentalism, you can include events like the florida school shooting and such to that category. otherwise, it's probably at number 2 over islam. heck, the state of israel is probably higher up on the food chain with how it treats its muslim minority / the palestinians.
User avatar
AD
Posts: 23656
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 10:30 pm
Location: Here
Has given rep: 557 times
Received rep: 648 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1646 by AD » Mon Apr 01, 2019 9:10 am

Extremist Muslims, the Likud in Israel and White Nationalist are all right wing fundamentalists. EB mind blown.
User avatar
Boring Choice #2
Posts: 6607
Joined: Fri Dec 28, 1979 6:06 am
Has given rep: 541 times
Received rep: 580 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1647 by Boring Choice #2 » Mon Apr 01, 2019 10:20 am

if it weren't for this shitty website being incapable / me being too lazy to make an image hosting account, i'd be so tempted to make a pie chart right now.
User avatar
jester
Registered Broad
Posts: 7108
Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2008 2:38 pm
Has given rep: 10 times
Received rep: 134 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1648 by jester » Mon Apr 01, 2019 10:47 am

Craig wrote:What I don't get is how you think religions can outgrow their badness, then turn around and criticise the religion for the acts of its adherents instead of the socio-economic and geopolitical conditions that surround it. I don't think religions outgrow their nasties on their own, external things change their constituents who in turn moderate their religion.


Fat and happy = moderating force on violent tendencies.

Not fat and happy = exacerbating force on violent tendencies.

Timeline of truth for this? All of recorded human history, and the archeological record of pre-civilization man.

Even then, of course, much of this argument rests on a deeply ahistorical analysis that is either purposeful in its omissions or grounded in ignorance. We just finished the centennial celebration of the conflict that began Europe's self-immolation (which had nothing to do with Islam, and was largely driven by secularist ideologies) in the first half of the 20th c. In the coming years, we can celebrate the centennial "celebrations" of Stalin's policies and its victims, the Third Reich, Mao and the 30-38 million dead from his policies, etc.

Not to mention, just to stick to the subject of white nationalism, there is a whole host of folks alive and kicking in the US South that attended or are the children of participants in lynchings, etc.

Alternative theory of fat and happy status in much of the industrialized world: it killed off most of the threats to it ... and is armed to the teeth still.
User avatar
Dog
Registered Broad
Posts: 297
Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2008 2:53 pm
Has given rep: 1620 times
Received rep: 30 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1649 by Dog » Mon Apr 01, 2019 11:12 am

I read an interesting thing once about Chimps and Bonobos. Seems humans are related to a shared common ancestor, before the split between Chimps and Bonobos. The split occurred when groups were separated by the congo river, with Chimps in a land of less plenty developping more aggressive tendencies and bonobos in a land of more plenty basically solving every social tension by fucking. The two can still interbreed in captivity, so aren’t that morphologically different. More a culture/environment thing.
User avatar
shredz
Registered Broad
Posts: 34073
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 3:31 pm
Location: Rock Bottom, NY
Has given rep: 2159 times
Received rep: 1048 times

Re: IS this discussion done now? Broads discuss the root cause of evil.

Post #1650 by shredz » Thu Apr 04, 2019 1:37 pm


Return to “Le mur de messages”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Murphy and 1 guest